New TV:
Hot Properties (ABC, Friday, 7,30)
Nicole Sullivan + hot, funny girl who looks a lot like Rachel McAdams + two other non-funny hot women + the bald guy who played Doug the campaign speechwriter on the fourth season of "The West Wing" = hilarity?
No, no it doesn't. Predictable. Tired. Boring. D. But, man, Christina Moore is a fox.
Freddie (CBS, Wednesday, 7,30)
This show airs right before "Lost"--the best show on TV--and it's not very funny. I watched for Madchen Amick, of "I was awesome on ER. Then I was OK on Joey. And now I'm crappy on 'Freddie.' Man, my career sucks. But I sure do have a cool name!" fame. She was not funny. Freddie was not funny. Brian Austin Greene (David from 90210) was funny, which I totally did not see coming. As was his subplot. But that was about it. We'll see how this goes, at least for another two weeks. But so far, it's precisely what I expected from a post-"Drew Carey Show" Bruce Helford and Freddie Prinze Jr.: Not funny. D.
Related (The WB, Wednesday, 8,00)
This show is up against "Lost," so, unless you don't like Lost because you're dumb or you're waiting for it to come out on DVD so you can see it in it's intended 1.85:1 aspect ration, don't watch this show. Watch "Lost" instead.
Also in this time slot is "Criminal Minds." Which is very good, too, but about psycho/socio-pathy, so not exactly pulling from this show's target audience. Also in this timeslot, Marth Stewart's Apprentice (which I refuse to watch).
So, lets break this down, if each of us could only watch one show at this time, this is how it would break down:
"Lost" would be watched by me.
"Criminal Minds" was MADE for Matt.
MStewart's Apprentice seems like Lars or Michelle-ish fare.
"Related" would be watched by Kathleen.
It's perfect for her. From a former executive producer of "Sex in the City" and with a little touch up work done by Marta Kaufmann, co-creator of "Friends," it's girly. And fun. And because I'm girly, I probably liked it much more than I should have. But I'll tell you this, the second episode was much better than the first. Lets hope it keeps improving. A, if you're Kathleen. B- if you're me. D if you're Matt.
PS: The entire pilot was shot with Laura San Giocomo in the role of Ann. Kaufmann didn't like the way she carried it, so she got shitcanned and replaced by a relative unknown. Ouch, Marta, that's harsh.
//
Updates on already reviewed shows:
"My Name is Earl"
Is funnier than I gave it credit for being. Last weeks episode ("Faked his Own Death") was genuinely funny throughout. And it doesn't hurt that "The Office" airs right after, and it really is spinedestroyingly funny. And Jason Lee's getting more comfortable as Earl and not drawing such crappy plots as the first two episodes. "My Name is Earl," Matt was right about you, you're funny. Upgraded to B.
"Everybody Hates Chris"
Also funnier than I gave it credit for being. It's settled into a nice little groove, but I can't get over the feeling that it's 20 minutes worth of funny in a 30 minute show. Rock carries it, though, and the kid that plays him is hilarious, as are the mother and father. Upgraded to C.
"Invasion"/"Threshold"
Alright, it's time for me to fess up. I blew the call on this one. Threshold was wonderfully frontloaded with revelations and hard sci-fi. Invasion, however, is unfolding beautifully, terribly, wonderfully slowly, letting you make your own assumptions and then either ratifying them or forcing you to change them at its own deliberate pace.
"Threshold" is that girl that flashed you while you were driving down the interstate, and that's hot and all, but "Invasion" is the girl who whispers in your ear all sexy and eventually you put your hand on her hip and it just about drives you wild with lust even though you really haven't gotten anywhere with her. And if you do ever get anywhere, it'll be on her timetable.
And I'm a sucker for a tease.
Threshold: Dowgraded to C.
Invasion: Upgraded to A.
"How I Met Your Mother"
The episode "The Sweet Taste of Liberty" was, so far, the defining episode for this show. So much so that I transfered it off the ReplayTV to my computer and re-encoded it small enough to fit on a CD. So if you're curious what I'm talking about when I blow my load all over HIMYM, I'll burn it on a CD and send it to you. Seriously.
That said: HIMYM's not as funny as "The Office" is now. But it's far funnier than "The Office" was last season, so if we all get behind it, I'm confident it'll blossom into the best comedy on TV.
"Just Legal," "Head Cases," "Inconcievable"
I totally called it: these shows sucked and have already been canceled. Suck on that, TV executives. Maybe you'll let me preview your fall season next year before you pick up DON FUCKING JOHNSON as a LAWYER.
"Alias"
It's so sad to watch a terriffic show go down the crapper.
//
So what does this all mean to you? I'm going to provide here a list of shows you should be watching and what channel and what time they're on. Shows in red are shows YOU CANNOT MISS.
Arrested Development
Monday, 7,00, Fox
How I Met Your Mother
Monday, 7,30, CBS
# Alternate: If HIMYM isn't your cuppa, try out Kitchen Confidential, Monday, 7,30, Fox.
Out of Practice
Monday, 8,30, CBS
Medium
Monday, 9,00, NBC
Bones
Tuesday, 7,00, Fox
(That is, if you're not already hung up on "Gilmore Girls.")
My Name is Earl
Tuesday, 8,00, NBC
The Office
Tuesday, 8,30, NBC
Winner: Funniest show on TV
# Alternate Picks: Commander in Chief (ABC) or Supernatural (WB) are good 8,00PM Tuesday picks.
Lost
Wednesday, 8,00, ABC
Winner: BEST show on TV
# Alternate Pick: There's no substituting for Lost, but if you've gotta watch something else, "Criminal Minds" is awesome, if you like creepy people murdering other people and other creepy but well groomed people tracking them down. "Related" is good if you like cute girls having cute girl-trouble.
Invasion
Wednesday, 9,00, ABC
Reunion
Thursday, 8,00, Fox
# I know, CSI should be the pick for this spot, but Reunion's the sleeper show of the fall. Check it out, if you can afford to put off your CSI fix until it comes on just a little later on Spike TV.
Threshold
Friday, 8,00, CBS
If you've come this far, might as well continue. If not, don't bother.
The West Wing
Sunday, 7,00, NBC
# C'mon, it's the West Wing. A shadow of its former self, sure, but watch it anyway.
Alternate pick: The War at Home, Sunday, 8,30, Fox. Funny enough.
American Dad
Sunday, Fox, 8,30
# Funnier than "Family Guy." I know, it's wierd.
Grey's Anatomy
Sunday, 9,00, ABC
# Soap opera done right.
//
Breakdown of new fall TV grades, from first to worst (with graph!)
1 How I Met Your Mother A
2 Invasion A
3 Reuinion B
4 Criminal Minds B
5 My Name is Earl B
6 Out of Practice B
7 Kitchen Confidential B-
8 Commander in Chief B-
9 Related B-
10 Threshold C
11 Bones C
12 The War at Home C
13 Everybody Hates Chris C
14 Surface C
15 E-Ring C
16 Supernatural C-
17 Twins C-
18 Close to Home C-
19 Freddie D
20 Hot Properties D
21 Just Legal D
22 Inconcievable D
23 Night Stalker F
24 Ghost Whisperer F
Grade distribution chart:
A pretty good curve, if you ask me, and I swear to you, I didn't intend for it to turn out symmetrical.